Cleveland Indians pitcher Zach Plesac is on the injured list with a non-displaced fracture of his right thumb — a relatively normal thing for a pitcher to suffer in the course of his job. The thing is, according to Indians manager Terry Francona, Plesac didn’t get hurt fielding a comebacker or throwing too hard; he fractured his thumb by “rather aggressively ripping off his shirt.” Seriously.
Plesac now joins a bizarre club: athletes who were injured in extremely nontraditional ways. From off-field accidents to celebrations gone wrong, here’s a list of the strangest ways players have missed time over the past 20 years.
While playing for the Arizona Cardinals in 2001, Bill Gramatica hit a routine field goal to put his team up 3-0 in the first quarter of a mid-December matchup against the New York Giants. The place-kicker jumped up in celebration, landed awkwardly and tore his ACL. “I couldn’t tell you right now what I’m going to do,” Gramatica said about his celebrations a few months later, “but I know it’s not going to be jumping around.”
Looking to fire up his team, Jacksonville Jaguars coach Jack del Rio brought an ax and an oak stump into the locker room to remind the squad to “keep choppin’ wood.” Jaguars punter Chris Hanson accidentally gashed himself while wielding the axe, and he missed the remainder of the 2003 season as a result.
Clint Barmes was hitting .329 in a breakout 2005 campaign for the Colorado Rockies when the unthinkable happened: He fell and broke his collarbone while carrying a package of deer meat given to him by teammate Todd Helton. Barmes would miss three months and finish the season at .289.
At the 2008 Miami Masters tennis tournament, Mikhail Youzhny hit a return against Nicolas Almagro into the net. Youzhny responded by smashing his forehead with his racket three times, drawing blood. The truly odd thing? Youzhny ended up winning the match.
In 2008, Detroit Tigers catcher Brandon Inge was adjusting a pillow behind his 3-year-old son’s head when he somehow pulled an oblique muscle and landed on the 15-day injured list.
Kendrys Morales hit a walk-off grand slam against the Seattle Mariners in May 2010. When he reached home plate, he jumped in the middle of his Los Angeles Angels teammates in celebration … and broke his lower left leg when he landed. Morales would miss the remainder of the season.
The pancakes that former Los Angeles Kings forward Dustin Penner’s wife makes must be delicious, because he suffered back spasms while eating them back in 2012. Fortunately, he only ended up missing a single game.
Summer frostbite isn’t an unprecedented reason for a player to miss time — it famously happened to MLB outfielder Rickey Henderson once, after he fell asleep on an ice pack — but it’s certainly not something anyone expected to happen.