Fantasy Football Dynasty Superflex Startup Mock Draft Results: Jonathan Taylor leads 45 rookies drafted


For the first time in 2020 we included rookies in a Dynasty startup mock, and as you might imagine, they were quite popular. Jonathan Taylor was the first off the board in the second round, and it didn’t take long before several followed him. This was a Superflex mock, which made the equation even more interesting. 

Taylor was the only rookie taken in the first 30 picks, and because of the format, Joe Burrow was next at the end of the third. D’Andre Swift went with the next pick and then Tua Tagovailoa went early in the fourth round. Burrow and Tagovailoa were the ninth and 10th quarterbacks off the board, just ahead of Matt Ryan and Baker Mayfield. It’s hard to imagine landing spot have much impact on them, but it plays a major factor in where some of the running backs and wide receivers will go.

The only other rookie to be drafted in the first 50 picks was J.K. Dobbins, my fourth round pick. If Dobbins landed in a feature role in the first two rounds of the NFL Draft, I could see him going as early as the second round in startups, but if he falls he could easily go a round or two later than this. 

We didn’t see a rookie receiver taken until Round 5, when CeeDee Lamb went off the board. Jerry Jeudy went almost a full round later in Round 6. While that seems pretty late for the top two receivers in the class it’s worth noting that Marquise Brown (Round 10) and N’Keal Harry (Round 11) went much later. 

All told there were 45 rookies selected in this 20-round draft. Less than a third of them (14) were taken in the single-digit rounds. Wide receivers dominated, with 21 selections, followed by running back (13) and quarterback (eight). There were only three rookie tight ends drafted, none before Round 16.

The NFL Draft will change the order and maybe even the number of rookies worth drafting in a startup, but this gives you a good idea of how we value them before we know their landing spots. 

The analysts who participated in this mock are:

Scott Fish, Scott Fish Bowl/Fantasy Cares
Ben Schragger, CBS Sports
Dwight Peebles, Dynasty League Football
Joseph Nammour, Dynasty League Football
Heath Cummings, CBS Sports
Ben Gretch, CBS Sports
Nathan Powell, Dynasty League Football
Travis May, Dynasty Command
Gabriel Geering, The Open Bar Pod
John Bosch, Dynasty Wall Street
Dave Richard, CBS Sports
Jamey Eisenberg, CBS Sports

And here are the results:

Round By Round

Round 1
Pos Team Player
1 Scott Fish P. Mahomes QB KC
2 Ben Schragger C. McCaffrey RB CAR
3 Dwight Peebles L. Jackson QB BAL
4 Joseph Nammour S. Barkley RB NYG
5 Heath Cummings M. Thomas WR NO
6 Ben Gretch A. Kamara RB NO
7 Nathan Powell E. Elliott RB DAL
8 Travis May D. Cook RB MIN
9 Gabe Geering D. Watson QB HOU
10 John Bosch K. Murray QB ARI
11 Dave Richard T. Hill WR KC
12 Jamey Eisenberg D. Adams WR GB
Round 2
Pos Team Player
13 Jamey Eisenberg D. Hopkins WR ARI
14 Dave Richard C. Godwin WR TB
15 John Bosch J. Smith-Schuster WR PIT
16 Gabe Geering M. Evans WR TB
17 Travis May J. Taylor RB FA
18 Nathan Powell R. Wilson QB SEA
19 Ben Gretch D. Moore WR CAR
20 Heath Cummings G. Kittle TE SF
21 Joseph Nammour J. Mixon RB CIN
22 Dwight Peebles N. Chubb RB CLE
23 Ben Schragger D. Prescott QB DAL
24 Scott Fish J. Jacobs RB LV
Round 3
Pos Team Player
25 Scott Fish M. Sanders RB PHI
26 Ben Schragger A. Jones RB GB
27 Dwight Peebles J. Jones WR ATL
28 Joseph Nammour J. Allen QB BUF
29 Heath Cummings C. Sutton WR DEN
30 Ben Gretch A. Brown WR TEN
31 Nathan Powell A. Cooper WR DAL
32 Travis May C. Wentz QB PHI
33 Gabe Geering J. Burrow QB FA
34 John Bosch D. Swift RB FA
35 Dave Richard A. Ekeler RB LAC
36 Jamey Eisenberg K. Drake RB ARI
Round 4
Pos Team Player
37 Jamey Eisenberg D. Henry RB TEN
38 Dave Richard C. Kupp WR LAR
39 John Bosch T. Tagovailoa QB FA
40 Gabe Geering O. Beckham WR CLE
41 Travis May M. Ryan QB ATL
42 Nathan Powell B. Mayfield QB CLE
43 Ben Gretch M. Stafford QB DET
44 Heath Cummings J. Dobbins RB FA
45 Joseph Nammour T. Kelce TE KC
46 Dwight Peebles A. Rodgers QB GB
47 Ben Schragger C. Ridley WR ATL
48 Scott Fish K. Golladay WR DET
Round 5
Pos Team Player
49 Scott Fish D. Metcalf WR SEA
50 Ben Schragger L. Fournette RB JAC
51 Dwight Peebles C. Akers RB FA
52 Joseph Nammour C. Lamb WR FA
53 Heath Cummings D. Jones QB NYG
54 Ben Gretch J. Goff QB LAR
55 Nathan Powell S. Diggs WR BUF
56 Travis May K. Allen WR LAC
57 Gabe Geering A. Robinson WR CHI
58 John Bosch C. Edwards-Helaire RB FA
59 Dave Richard D. Singletary RB BUF
60 Jamey Eisenberg T. Brady QB TB
Round 6
Pos Team Player
61 Jamey Eisenberg D. Brees QB NO
62 Dave Richard Z. Ertz TE PHI
63 John Bosch J. Jeudy WR FA
64 Gabe Geering T. Gurley RB ATL
65 Travis May L. Bell RB NYJ
66 Nathan Powell T. Lockett WR SEA
67 Ben Gretch T. McLaurin WR WAS
68 Heath Cummings M. Mack RB IND
69 Joseph Nammour D. Chark WR JAC
70 Dwight Peebles J. Garoppolo QB SF
71 Ben Schragger M. Gallup WR DAL
72 Scott Fish M. Andrews TE BAL
Round 7
Pos Team Player
73 Scott Fish D. Samuel WR SF
74 Ben Schragger S. Darnold QB NYJ
75 Dwight Peebles B. Cooks WR HOU
76 Joseph Nammour T. Boyd WR CIN
77 Heath Cummings D. Henderson RB LAR
78 Ben Gretch K. Johnson RB DET
79 Nathan Powell J. Herbert QB FA
80 Travis May R. Woods WR LAR
81 Gabe Geering D. Guice RB WAS
82 John Bosch A. Thielen WR MIN
83 Dave Richard R. Tannehill QB TEN
84 Jamey Eisenberg T. Hilton WR IND
Round 8
Pos Team Player
85 Jamey Eisenberg M. Gordon RB LAC
86 Dave Richard C. Carson RB SEA
87 John Bosch D. Montgomery RB CHI
88 Gabe Geering E. Engram TE NYG
89 Travis May J. Landry WR CLE
90 Nathan Powell H. Ruggs III WR FA
91 Ben Gretch C. Kirk WR ARI
92 Heath Cummings D. Lock QB DEN
93 Joseph Nammour K. Cousins QB MIN
94 Dwight Peebles D. Johnson RB HOU
95 Ben Schragger J. Conner RB PIT
96 Scott Fish D. Slayton WR NYG
Round 9
Pos Team Player
97 Scott Fish T. Bridgewater QB CAR
98 Ben Schragger D. Waller TE LV
99 Dwight Peebles J. Jefferson WR FA
100 Joseph Nammour J. Reagor WR FA
101 Heath Cummings G. Minshew QB JAC
102 Ben Gretch W. Fuller WR HOU
103 Nathan Powell D. Haskins QB WAS
104 Travis May A. Green WR CIN
105 Gabe Geering M. Williams WR LAC
106 John Bosch B. Roethlisberger QB PIT
107 Dave Richard J. Hurts QB FA
108 Jamey Eisenberg C. Newton QB CAR
Round 10
Pos Team Player
109 Jamey Eisenberg D. Williams RB KC
110 Dave Richard J. Love QB FA
111 John Bosch N. Fant TE DEN
112 Gabe Geering P. Rivers QB IND
113 Travis May D. Mims WR FA
114 Nathan Powell K. Hunt RB CLE
115 Ben Gretch N. Foles QB CHI
116 Heath Cummings M. Brown WR BAL
117 Joseph Nammour D. Johnson WR PIT
118 Dwight Peebles H. Henry TE LAC
119 Ben Schragger D. Carr QB LV
120 Scott Fish J. Stidham QB NE
Round 11
Pos Team Player
121 Scott Fish J. Winston QB TB
122 Ben Schragger D. Parker WR MIA
123 Dwight Peebles S. Shepard WR NYG
124 Joseph Nammour N. Harry WR NE
125 Heath Cummings R. Jones RB TB
126 Ben Gretch L. Shenault Jr. WR FA
127 Nathan Powell O. Howard TE TB
128 Travis May T. Higgins WR FA
129 Gabe Geering A. Mattison RB MIN
130 John Bosch M. Hardman WR KC
131 Dave Richard T. Higbee TE LAR
132 Jamey Eisenberg T. Taylor QB LAC
Round 12
Pos Team Player
133 Jamey Eisenberg B. Aiyuk WR FA
134 Dave Richard T. Cohen RB CHI
135 John Bosch C. Samuel WR CAR
136 Gabe Geering T. Hockenson TE DET
137 Travis May M. Ingram RB BAL
138 Nathan Powell A. Dillon RB FA
139 Ben Gretch M. Gesicki TE MIA
140 Heath Cummings Z. Moss RB FA
141 Joseph Nammour A. Hooper TE CLE
142 Dwight Peebles J. Brown WR BUF
143 Ben Schragger J. Howard RB MIA
144 Scott Fish J. Hill RB BAL
Round 13
Pos Team Player
145 Scott Fish T. Pollard RB DAL
146 Ben Schragger M. Trubisky QB CHI
147 Dwight Peebles A. Miller WR CHI
148 Joseph Nammour M. Pittman Jr. WR FA
149 Heath Cummings S. Michel RB NE
150 Ben Gretch D. Goedert TE PHI
151 Nathan Powell I. Smith TE MIN
152 Travis May P. Lindsay RB DEN
153 Gabe Geering P. Campbell WR IND
154 John Bosch R. Anderson WR CAR
155 Dave Richard T. Hill QB NO
156 Jamey Eisenberg J. Smith TE TEN
Round 14
Pos Team Player
157 Jamey Eisenberg N. Hines RB IND
158 Dave Richard B. Perriman WR NYJ
159 John Bosch M. Jones WR DET
160 Gabe Geering K. Vaughn RB FA
161 Travis May H. Hurst TE ATL
162 Nathan Powell J. Arcega-Whiteside WR PHI
163 Ben Gretch E. Benjamin RB FA
164 Heath Cummings P. Williams WR MIA
165 Joseph Nammour A. Dalton QB CIN
166 Dwight Peebles R. Penny RB SEA
167 Ben Schragger H. Renfrow WR LV
168 Scott Fish I. Thomas TE CAR
Round 15
Pos Team Player
169 Scott Fish T. Williams RB CIN
170 Ben Schragger B. Edwards WR FA
171 Dwight Peebles A. Gibson WR FA
172 Joseph Nammour J. Jackson RB LAC
173 Heath Cummings J. Edelman WR NE
174 Ben Gretch M. Brown RB LAR
175 Nathan Powell D. Harris RB NE
176 Travis May A. Okwuegbunam TE FA
177 Gabe Geering T. Johnson WR FA
178 John Bosch C. Claypool WR FA
179 Dave Richard V. Jefferson WR FA
180 Jamey Eisenberg C. Edmonds RB ARI
Round 16
Pos Team Player
181 Jamey Eisenberg A. Gandy-Golden WR FA
182 Dave Richard G. Edwards RB BAL
183 John Bosch A. McFarland Jr. RB FA
184 Gabe Geering C. Davis WR TEN
185 Travis May D. Evans RB FA
186 Nathan Powell J. Fromm QB FA
187 Ben Gretch R. Mostert RB SF
188 Heath Cummings J. Crowder WR NYJ
189 Joseph Nammour J. White RB NE
190 Dwight Peebles E. Ebron TE DET
191 Ben Schragger J. Ross WR CIN
192 Scott Fish D. Njoku TE CLE
Round 17
Pos Team Player
193 Scott Fish J. Washington WR PIT
194 Ben Schragger J. Williams RB GB
195 Dwight Peebles J. Brissett QB IND
196 Joseph Nammour J. Eason QB FA
197 Heath Cummings R. Fitzpatrick QB MIA
198 Ben Gretch T. Coleman RB SF
199 Nathan Powell A. Jeffery WR PHI
200 Travis May J. Sternberger TE GB
201 Gabe Geering J. Kelley RB FA
202 John Bosch E. Sanders WR NO
203 Dave Richard K. Hamler WR FA
204 Jamey Eisenberg S. Watkins WR KC
Round 18
Pos Team Player
205 Jamey Eisenberg D. Thompson RB KC
206 Dave Richard B. Jarwin TE DAL
207 John Bosch D. Duvernay WR FA
208 Gabe Geering M. Mariota QB TEN
209 Travis May L. Fitzgerald WR ARI
210 Nathan Powell D. Westbrook WR JAC
211 Ben Gretch B. Love RB WAS
212 Heath Cummings J. Doyle TE IND
213 Joseph Nammour J. Cook TE NO
214 Dwight Peebles T. Williams WR LV
215 Ben Schragger D. Freeman RB ATL
216 Scott Fish A. Isabella WR ARI
Round 19
Pos Team Player
217 Scott Fish A. Lazard WR GB
218 Ben Schragger P. Walker QB CAR
219 Dwight Peebles B. Hopkins TE FA
220 Joseph Nammour G. Tate WR NYG
221 Heath Cummings J. Reynolds WR LAR
222 Ben Gretch R. Freeman RB DEN
223 Nathan Powell K. Rudolph TE MIN
224 Travis May D. Johnson RB HOU
225 Gabe Geering M. Boykin WR BAL
226 John Bosch D. Peoples-Jones WR FA
227 Dave Richard D. Parham TE LAC
228 Jamey Eisenberg C. Herndon TE NYJ
Round 20
Pos Team Player
229 Jamey Eisenberg L. Murray RB NO
230 Dave Richard J. Hurd WR SF
231 John Bosch D. Knox TE BUF
232 Gabe Geering L. Perine RB FA
233 Travis May D. Washington RB KC
234 Nathan Powell A. Gordon QB FA
235 Ben Gretch J. Richard RB LV
236 Heath Cummings A. Brown WR FA
237 Joseph Nammour L. Bowden Jr. WR FA
238 Dwight Peebles I. Hodgins WR FA
239 Ben Schragger B. Scott RB PHI
240 Scott Fish A. Tate WR CIN

Team by Team

Scott Fish
Rd Pk Player
1 1 P. Mahomes QB KC
2 24 J. Jacobs RB LV
3 25 M. Sanders RB PHI
4 48 K. Golladay WR DET
5 49 D. Metcalf WR SEA
6 72 M. Andrews TE BAL
7 73 D. Samuel WR SF
8 96 D. Slayton WR NYG
9 97 T. Bridgewater QB CAR
10 120 J. Stidham QB NE
11 121 J. Winston QB TB
12 144 J. Hill RB BAL
13 145 T. Pollard RB DAL
14 168 I. Thomas TE CAR
15 169 T. Williams RB CIN
16 192 D. Njoku TE CLE
17 193 J. Washington WR PIT
18 216 A. Isabella WR ARI
19 217 A. Lazard WR GB
20 240 A. Tate WR CIN
Ben Schragger
Rd Pk Player
1 2 C. McCaffrey RB CAR
2 23 D. Prescott QB DAL
3 26 A. Jones RB GB
4 47 C. Ridley WR ATL
5 50 L. Fournette RB JAC
6 71 M. Gallup WR DAL
7 74 S. Darnold QB NYJ
8 95 J. Conner RB PIT
9 98 D. Waller TE LV
10 119 D. Carr QB LV
11 122 D. Parker WR MIA
12 143 J. Howard RB MIA
13 146 M. Trubisky QB CHI
14 167 H. Renfrow WR LV
15 170 B. Edwards WR FA
16 191 J. Ross WR CIN
17 194 J. Williams RB GB
18 215 D. Freeman RB ATL
19 218 P. Walker QB CAR
20 239 B. Scott RB PHI
Dwight Peebles
Rd Pk Player
1 3 L. Jackson QB BAL
2 22 N. Chubb RB CLE
3 27 J. Jones WR ATL
4 46 A. Rodgers QB GB
5 51 C. Akers RB FA
6 70 J. Garoppolo QB SF
7 75 B. Cooks WR HOU
8 94 D. Johnson RB HOU
9 99 J. Jefferson WR FA
10 118 H. Henry TE LAC
11 123 S. Shepard WR NYG
12 142 J. Brown WR BUF
13 147 A. Miller WR CHI
14 166 R. Penny RB SEA
15 171 A. Gibson WR FA
16 190 E. Ebron TE DET
17 195 J. Brissett QB IND
18 214 T. Williams WR LV
19 219 B. Hopkins TE FA
20 238 I. Hodgins WR FA
Joseph Nammour
Rd Pk Player
1 4 S. Barkley RB NYG
2 21 J. Mixon RB CIN
3 28 J. Allen QB BUF
4 45 T. Kelce TE KC
5 52 C. Lamb WR FA
6 69 D. Chark WR JAC
7 76 T. Boyd WR CIN
8 93 K. Cousins QB MIN
9 100 J. Reagor WR FA
10 117 D. Johnson WR PIT
11 124 N. Harry WR NE
12 141 A. Hooper TE CLE
13 148 M. Pittman Jr. WR FA
14 165 A. Dalton QB CIN
15 172 J. Jackson RB LAC
16 189 J. White RB NE
17 196 J. Eason QB FA
18 213 J. Cook TE NO
19 220 G. Tate WR NYG
20 237 L. Bowden Jr. WR FA
Heath Cummings
Rd Pk Player
1 5 M. Thomas WR NO
2 20 G. Kittle TE SF
3 29 C. Sutton WR DEN
4 44 J. Dobbins RB FA
5 53 D. Jones QB NYG
6 68 M. Mack RB IND
7 77 D. Henderson RB LAR
8 92 D. Lock QB DEN
9 101 G. Minshew QB JAC
10 116 M. Brown WR BAL
11 125 R. Jones RB TB
12 140 Z. Moss RB FA
13 149 S. Michel RB NE
14 164 P. Williams WR MIA
15 173 J. Edelman WR NE
16 188 J. Crowder WR NYJ
17 197 R. Fitzpatrick QB MIA
18 212 J. Doyle TE IND
19 221 J. Reynolds WR LAR
20 236 A. Brown WR FA
Ben Gretch
Rd Pk Player
1 6 A. Kamara RB NO
2 19 D. Moore WR CAR
3 30 A. Brown WR TEN
4 43 M. Stafford QB DET
5 54 J. Goff QB LAR
6 67 T. McLaurin WR WAS
7 78 K. Johnson RB DET
8 91 C. Kirk WR ARI
9 102 W. Fuller WR HOU
10 115 N. Foles QB CHI
11 126 L. Shenault Jr. WR FA
12 139 M. Gesicki TE MIA
13 150 D. Goedert TE PHI
14 163 E. Benjamin RB FA
15 174 M. Brown RB LAR
16 187 R. Mostert RB SF
17 198 T. Coleman RB SF
18 211 B. Love RB WAS
19 222 R. Freeman RB DEN
20 235 J. Richard RB LV
Nathan Powell
Rd Pk Player
1 7 E. Elliott RB DAL
2 18 R. Wilson QB SEA
3 31 A. Cooper WR DAL
4 42 B. Mayfield QB CLE
5 55 S. Diggs WR BUF
6 66 T. Lockett WR SEA
7 79 J. Herbert QB FA
8 90 H. Ruggs III WR FA
9 103 D. Haskins QB WAS
10 114 K. Hunt RB CLE
11 127 O. Howard TE TB
12 138 A. Dillon RB FA
13 151 I. Smith TE MIN
14 162 J. Arcega-Whiteside WR PHI
15 175 D. Harris RB NE
16 186 J. Fromm QB FA
17 199 A. Jeffery WR PHI
18 210 D. Westbrook WR JAC
19 223 K. Rudolph TE MIN
20 234 A. Gordon QB FA
Travis May
Rd Pk Player
1 8 D. Cook RB MIN
2 17 J. Taylor RB FA
3 32 C. Wentz QB PHI
4 41 M. Ryan QB ATL
5 56 K. Allen WR LAC
6 65 L. Bell RB NYJ
7 80 R. Woods WR LAR
8 89 J. Landry WR CLE
9 104 A. Green WR CIN
10 113 D. Mims WR FA
11 128 T. Higgins WR FA
12 137 M. Ingram RB BAL
13 152 P. Lindsay RB DEN
14 161 H. Hurst TE ATL
15 176 A. Okwuegbunam TE FA
16 185 D. Evans RB FA
17 200 J. Sternberger TE GB
18 209 L. Fitzgerald WR ARI
19 224 D. Johnson RB HOU
20 233 D. Washington RB KC
Gabe Geering
Rd Pk Player
1 9 D. Watson QB HOU
2 16 M. Evans WR TB
3 33 J. Burrow QB FA
4 40 O. Beckham WR CLE
5 57 A. Robinson WR CHI
6 64 T. Gurley RB ATL
7 81 D. Guice RB WAS
8 88 E. Engram TE NYG
9 105 M. Williams WR LAC
10 112 P. Rivers QB IND
11 129 A. Mattison RB MIN
12 136 T. Hockenson TE DET
13 153 P. Campbell WR IND
14 160 K. Vaughn RB FA
15 177 T. Johnson WR FA
16 184 C. Davis WR TEN
17 201 J. Kelley RB FA
18 208 M. Mariota QB TEN
19 225 M. Boykin WR BAL
20 232 L. Perine RB FA
John Bosch
Rd Pk Player
1 10 K. Murray QB ARI
2 15 J. Smith-Schuster WR PIT
3 34 D. Swift RB FA
4 39 T. Tagovailoa QB FA
5 58 C. Edwards-Helaire RB FA
6 63 J. Jeudy WR FA
7 82 A. Thielen WR MIN
8 87 D. Montgomery RB CHI
9 106 B. Roethlisberger QB PIT
10 111 N. Fant TE DEN
11 130 M. Hardman WR KC
12 135 C. Samuel WR CAR
13 154 R. Anderson WR CAR
14 159 M. Jones WR DET
15 178 C. Claypool WR FA
16 183 A. McFarland Jr. RB FA
17 202 E. Sanders WR NO
18 207 D. Duvernay WR FA
19 226 D. Peoples-Jones WR FA
20 231 D. Knox TE BUF
Dave Richard
Rd Pk Player
1 11 T. Hill WR KC
2 14 C. Godwin WR TB
3 35 A. Ekeler RB LAC
4 38 C. Kupp WR LAR
5 59 D. Singletary RB BUF
6 62 Z. Ertz TE PHI
7 83 R. Tannehill QB TEN
8 86 C. Carson RB SEA
9 107 J. Hurts QB FA
10 110 J. Love QB FA
11 131 T. Higbee TE LAR
12 134 T. Cohen RB CHI
13 155 T. Hill QB NO
14 158 B. Perriman WR NYJ
15 179 V. Jefferson WR FA
16 182 G. Edwards RB BAL
17 203 K. Hamler WR FA
18 206 B. Jarwin TE DAL
19 227 D. Parham TE LAC
20 230 J. Hurd WR SF
Jamey Eisenberg
Rd Pk Player
1 12 D. Adams WR GB
2 13 D. Hopkins WR ARI
3 36 K. Drake RB ARI
4 37 D. Henry RB TEN
5 60 T. Brady QB TB
6 61 D. Brees QB NO
7 84 T. Hilton WR IND
8 85 M. Gordon RB LAC
9 108 C. Newton QB CAR
10 109 D. Williams RB KC
11 132 T. Taylor QB LAC
12 133 B. Aiyuk WR FA
13 156 J. Smith TE TEN
14 157 N. Hines RB IND
15 180 C. Edmonds RB ARI
16 181 A. Gandy-Golden WR FA
17 204 S. Watkins WR KC
18 205 D. Thompson RB KC
19 228 C. Herndon TE NYJ
20 229 L. Murray RB NO





Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *